也许在有些人眼里,海里翻滚着的只是一条条的鱼,就像在厨房的锅子里翻滚的一样。可是,那种鱼很聪明、会微笑……没有什么是不能吃的,可总有些食物会让我难过或者悚然,比如旺蛋、比如鱼翅——一条海豚拖着血尾朝着逃向导演,她好聪明,我好难过,这里是泪点!
片子之外,我能做什么呢?什么也做不了……片子结尾处说:这种情况还在继续——我相信一定在继续,与利益相关的事情,再龌龊也不会完全禁止!所以才悲愤!想改变这种状况太难了吧?!只是一片小小的海湾——要是被炸掉该多好,一举炸掉,一了百了,伤及人类也无所谓,反正都不无辜。
人类灭绝了,世界就和平了!
我永远站在海豚的立场上!
这部片子令我很失望,作为豆瓣评星最高的片子,表现出来的水准实在令我怀疑豆友们的鉴赏水平。
此片的最大硬伤就是预设立场,把太极村的居民,乃至整个日本国预先放在被告席上。而我认为,一部优秀的记录片应该只用镜头说话,除了必要的解释外,拍摄人员应该是中立的,沉默的。但是因为本片的摄制者同时又是活动的参与者,所以忍不住时时都要出来指手划脚一番,剥夺了观众独立思考,得出结论的权利,反而降低了本片的说服力。
本片说海豚肉有毒,这个很可疑,我几乎可以断定这是胡说。人吃鱼,海豚也吃鱼,为什么海豚身上就会汞超标呢?鲨鱼也是食物链顶端的动物,为什么吃鲨鱼就没问题呢?我从没听说过海豚有收集水银的本事。水俣病就更扯了,那是工业污染,和海豚一点关系没有。用水俣病人的形象来吓唬别人不要吃海豚肉,很卑鄙。
海豚会引起关注,无非是因为海豚特别可爱。但是正如本片一开头就指出的,海豚只是长着一副“笑脸”而已,并不表明它内心快乐与否。据我所知,八爪鱼和乌贼也很聪明(也许比海豚更聪明)
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1313104/board/nest/150119401
Chinese people cook and eat dogs and cats. We find that shocking and repulsive and want to put and end to it. They are so cute, how can we even think of eating them?
But wait,
We eat pigs and cows. The people from India find that shocking and repulsive and want to put an end to it. They are so holy, how can we even think of eating them?
But wait,
The people from India eat bugs and worms. The Japanese people find that shocking and repulsive and want to put and end to it. Worms are so slimy, how can they even think of eating them?
But wait,...
The Japanese people eat DOLPHINS AND WHALES. We find that shocking and repulsive and want to put an end to it. Dolphins are just like people for Christ's sake! Didn't God create Dolphin in his own image?
海豚湾:2009推荐,人类的相互理解尚且无法实现,谈何海豚?
转载请注明网址: https://www.bamatg.com/dm/id-1463.html